Meal Matchmaker is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

13 Valentine’s Day Gifts for Foodies you can buy Online

Foodie gifts for Valentine's Day
Last Updated on April 17, 2023

Who said you have to schlep around from shop to shop trying to find the tastiest or most unique gift for the foodie in your life? Certainly not us. In fact, we believe you can buy the perfect gift from the comfort of your mobile.

We have just about every type of online marketplace or food item for a plethora tastes and personalities.

If you want to give chocolate, wine, and sweets, we got you, peruse below.

Looking to venture out and give foodie bae something more adventurous or quirky like sea urchins or a pickle gift basket, then read on some more, we got info there, too!

Best Foodie Valentine’s Day Gifts

1. Hickory Farms (Editor’s Choice)

Hickory Farms

Y’all, this brand’s name is Amora which literally means love. HELLO, you know they know love, they are love, and you’ll get the hookup with them this Valentine’s day.

With their special coffee bundle, you’ll get 5 FREE gifts when you purchase two bags of Amora coffee and join their monthly subscription program.

The Coffee Bundle Includes:

  • 2 Bags of Amora Coffee
  • FREE 2 Amora Travel Mugs
  • FREE 12-Cup Coffee Maker
  • FREE Stainless Steel Canister
  • FREE Silver Scoop

2. Baked by Melissa

Cupcake delivery for Valentine's day by Baked by Melissa's

Baked by Melissa delivers bite-size cupcakes & treats. It’s the perfect gift for the boo in your life jonesing for a taste of this famous New York cupcake. Vegan & gluten-free cupcakes are available as well.

Baked by Melissa ships cupcakes and desserts nationwide via FedEx to arrive fresh. They offer next-day shipping M-F, or you can schedule ahead and choose an arrival date at checkout.

harry and david

Save 5% on orders $60 or more with Code CUPCAKELOVER5

3. Bake Me A Wish

Whether it’s heart-shaped cookies, cupcakes, cheesecakes, brownies, pies, or quiches, Bake Me a Wish has any baked good you could wish for. No, for real. It has EVERYTHING.

All their gifts include a greeting card where you can enter 250 characters to profess your love which will come on the card with the gift. Boom.

4. Fulton Fish Market

There’s lots of other fish in the sea this Valentine’s Day, especially when it comes to online shopping from Fulton Fish Market.

Offering just about every type of fish, shellfish, and items like caviar and sea urchins, these gifts will be a nice departure from sweets.

You’ll save 15% on their oysters & lobster tails and caviar & lobster tails kits with code XOXO.

5. Gourmet Gift Basket

You’ll be able to get all kinds of gift baskets or single items from this online market. Sure you can get bae conventional items such as Valentine’s themed popcorn tins, cheesecake bites, cakes, cookies and cheese with wine boards. But you’ll also be able to give gifts, above, called the “Beer My Valentine” bucket.

They ditched the chocolate and went with two gourmet flavors of popcorn, peppered beef jerky, roasted and salted peanuts and six delicious microbrews.

Whether you want more conventional gift baskets or something different, they offer it all!

6. Hickory Farms

Hickory Farms offers a bevy of Valentine’s themed gifts and baskets but this year, they’re offering 15% off select wine gifts.

7. igourmet

Valentine’s day allows many of us to be unabashedly cheesy; igourmet definitely helps in this endeavor with its many cheeses. But it doesn’t stop here; you can also get gourmet meat, artisanal oils, pasta, sauces, and a lot more.

8. Lobster Anywhere

Red marbled lobster raviolis with sea salt butter, center-cut filet mignon, and heart-shaped chocolate truffles? If that doesn’t say I love you, you’re a catch, then I don’t know what does.

Who said surf and turf can’t be romantic? AND it’s on sale for Valentine’s day!

9. Martha Stewart Wine

Martha Stewart is coming thru for y’all. Until February 14, 2020, you can get 30% off of your favorite wine with code VALENWINE30.

Get 25% off sitewide with code “VDAY”; offer good through Feb 16th, 2020.

We like the sound of that – Happy Valenwine’s day!

10. Milk Bar

Christina Tosi and Manhattan-based group Momofoku are behind the famous Milk bar, now a chain of the most delicious desserts and bakeries.

You don’t need to live in NYC to get a taste now that they deliver nationwide.

They have an online V’Day shop that provides many a yummy options. A word from the wise: give the milk bar pie, once known as crack pie, to yourself – didn’t anyone ever tell you you have to love yourself first?

You’ll receive free shipping on Valentine’s Day Treats on orders over $50; this offer is valid 1/24 – 2/12/2020.

11. Mouth

This online marketplace is witty as they are diverse in their offerings. Their Valentine’s day shop offers collections such as:

  • It Must’ve Brine Love: Pickle Gifts
  • Love On The Rocks: Whiskey Gifts
  • Hit Me With Your Best Shot: Cocktail Kits
  • It Had To Be Brew: Coffee Gifts
  • Meat Me In The Middle: Meat Gifts
  • That’s The Whey Love Goes: Cheese Gifts

…and so much more!

Mouth ships to all 50 states. They also ship any non-perishables (products that do not require insulation) to most military bases + APOs abroad which is another truly unique feature of this company.

12. Simply Chocolate

Simply Chocolates' selection of chocolate bars delivery service

Milk chocolate, dark chocolate, truffles, chocolate covered fruits, chocolate snacks, chocolate bars – y’all you name it, and if its chocolate, has chocolate on it, or in it, you can get it here!

13. Wicked Good Cupcakes

Cupcakes in jars shipped along with a lovely Lovepop 3D card containing your personal message? Yasss.

Each jar lasts up to 10 days without refrigeration. And you could freeze it upon arrival for up to 6 months, though I really don’t think you or bae could not have it right away.


Join the discussion here on Facebook.

Hi, I'm Paul. Welcome to my website! I, along with my cronies, are leveraging our years of working in the food industry to review meal and drink delivery services. We review. You eat happily ever after.

Read These Next

Exploring the Nordic Diet: What Is It and What Can You Eat?

Exploring the Nordic Diet: What Is It and What Can You Eat?

Benefits of a Vegetarian Diet

Benefits of a Vegetarian Diet

Types of Meat and Their Benefits: A Tasty Guide

Types of Meat and Their Benefits: A Tasty Guide

How To Transition To A Carnivore Diet

How To Transition To A Carnivore Diet

Top Choices: Best Carnivore Diet Supplements

Top Choices: Best Carnivore Diet Supplements

What Is The Sirtfood Diet?

What Is The Sirtfood Diet?
{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}