Meal Matchmaker is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

Sizzlefish Review: What’s the Scoop on This Sustainably Sourced Seafood Delivery Service?

Written By: Paul

Last Updated on December 23, 2021

Sizzlefish is a seafood delivery service that has been recommended by Forbes, HuffPost, and Bon Appetit magazines. The company has provided quality fish and seafood to US grocery companies for 30 years. Now, anyone can order food from the website can get seafood delivered to their door.

If you're into premium cuts of sustainably caught or farmed fish, keep reading to find out everything you need to know about the service.

Sizzlefish At A Glance

  • Best Match For: Families looking to bring more sustainably sourced seafood and fish into their diets without breaking the budget.
  • Commitment Level: Subscription
  • Availability: The contiguous US (No Alaska or Hawaii)
  • Value: $7.99-$8.99/serving; Free shipping
  • Type: Wild-caught or farm-raised frozen fish and seafood

How SizzleFish Works

With Sizzlefish, customers have two options for shopping: you can sign up for a recurring subscription or make a single purchase. The company's flexible subscription allows you to pick from three choices:

  • The Wild Fish Favorites Box. With this box, you'll get 12 hand-picked portions of seafood every month.
  • Sizzlefish Prime. This subscription lets you pick 14 servings of seafood, and you can select a delivery frequency between one and five weeks.
  • Sizzlefish Prime Plus. This option comes with 14 servings like the other subscription, but you have more options to choose from, such as red snapper, Mahi-Mahi, and tuna.

Once you create an account, you can manage your subscription online. Customers have the freedom to edit preferences, change the delivery frequency, or change the order's contents at any time. To cancel the subscription completely, you'll need to contact Sizzlefish customer service.

For a one-time order, you have a wide selection of fish and shellfish such as Wild Chilean Sea Bass, Jumbo Shrimp, Wild Atlantic Haddock, Chesapeake Soft Shell Crabs, and much more. Every item shows you how many portions come per order, as well as the reviews. You will also find certifications such as Keto & Paleo Friendly, Sustainable Fisheries, and Rich in Omega-3s.

Sizzlefish focuses on delivering only the highest-grade seafood. They are a Monterey Bay Aquarium Seafood Watch partner, meaning that their fishing practices are not harmful to the environment.

What You Can Expect From Your Meal

When you order from Sizzlefish, your fish will arrive at your door in a reusable cooler with dry ice. All of their items ship frozen, so you can store your fish in your freezer until you are ready to thaw and cook. If you want to learn more about why the fish ships flash-frozen, the company explains their decision in detail on the website.

If you choose to get a subscription, your orders will renew and ship automatically until you skip or cancel. You have the option to skip orders up to seven deliveries in advance.

Most of the fish is wild-caught except for the catfish, rainbow trout, and Atlantic salmon. They explain the difference between wild-caught and farmed fish in detail so that you can make an informed choice.

Sample Meals

Sizzlefish has a wide selection of seafood products, from salmon to scallops. If you are open to trying new things, consider signing up for the Wild Seafood Favorites box, which selects your monthly seafood for you. On any given month, you will receive a box of assorted fish such as softshell crabs, ahi tuna, lobster tails, smoked salmon, walleye, sockeye salmon, sea bass, shrimp, crab cakes, haddock, cod, sablefish, and halibut.

If you have special dietary needs or preferences, you should take a look at the Sizzlefish collections. There is a Healthy Eating collection, which includes whole30-compliant seafood, a paleo sampler, and an omega-3 protein mix. There's something for every type of health-conscious seafood-lover!

Though you can send any of their seafood subscriptions as gifts, the website also has a list of gift ideas. If your person likes to grill, check out the Wild Alaska Favorites BBQ box, which comes with sablefish, halibut, and sockeye salmon.


Sizzlefish ships products to any place within the contiguous US using FedEx. They do not ship to Alaska, Hawaii, nor PO boxes. The company ships orders on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays.

The best part about Sizzlefish is that all orders qualify for free shipping. If you want faster shipping, however, you will have to pay extra. For any other questions about your purchase, contact the Sizzlefish team for more information.


What is Sizzlefish?

Sizzlefish is an online seafood seller. It is a way for people at home or in the seafood industry to get quality cuts of fish and shellfish delivered. Sizzlefish delivers flash-frozen and sustainable products such as sockeye salmon, halibut, lobster, scallops, cod, and more directly from fishermen.

Who sells the best seafood online?

Sizzlefish is an online source of quality seafood. In addition to one-time orders of the best fish and seafood, customers can sign up for recurring seafood subscriptions right to their door. They offer a wide range of product choices, free shipping, and have great reviews from customers. Suzzlefish also keeps sustainability in mind.

Which fish is wild-caught?

At Sizzlefish, only the catfish, trout, and Atlantic salmon are farmed species. The website provides information for customers about wild-caught vs. farm-raised fish, and they assure that the food is high quality and sustainably sourced regardless.

Is Sizzlefish reputable?

Sizzlefish is a relatively new company, but they are quickly gaining a reputation of being one of the best fish delivery services. The shopping is easy, they have a great variety of fresh fish, and handling and shipping are managed professionally. In addition, their customer service is excellent.

How expensive is Sizzlefish?

You’ll have to pay $7.99-$8.99 for each serving of fish you order. Considering that shipping is free, these prices are pretty affordable.

Sizzlefish Costs

With a Sizzlefish subscription, you can choose 14 servings of fish and seafood for $7.99-$8.99 per serving. You can sign up for the newsletter and receive 10% off your first order. Shipping is free on all orders.

Pros & Cons


  • Free shipping on any order
  • Tons of information about seafood available on the Sizzlefish site
  • Great reviews on all-natural seafood selections
  • All product packaging includes handy recipes for your convenience


  • Cannot change the sizes of your subscription boxes or individual portions

Food for Thought

Seafood has many health benefits, which is why a place like Sizzlefish is so useful. Though the portions are a little large for a single-person household (there are over 14 pieces of fish in a pack), we can't deny the convenience of a Sizzlefish subscription. Since every product comes frozen at the peak of freshness, you can store your seafood for months until you're ready for it.

We love how Sizzlefish makes quality, sustainable fishing a priority and offers affordable shipping to customers. They also have a good variety of products, which means you won't feel like you have to eat the same foods over and over again.

Sizzlefish is the best match for people who want a source of quality seafood to feed the whole family.

SizzleFish delivers vacuum-sealed packaging sea foods products


  • Free shipping on any order
  • Tons of information about seafood available on the Sizzlefish site
  • Great reviews on all-natural seafood selections
  • All product packaging includes handy recipes for your convenience

Hi, I'm Paul. Welcome to my website! I, along with my cronies, are leveraging our years of working in the food industry to review meal and drink delivery services. We review. You eat happily ever after.

Related Posts:

Read These Next

Sun Basket vs Purple Carrot: Which is Best for You?

Sun Basket vs Purple Carrot: Which is Best for You?

Can You Meal Prep Steak? (Yes, Here’s How)

Can You Meal Prep Steak? (Yes, Here’s How)

How Long to Air Fry Frozen Sticks (+Essential Guide)

How Long to Air Fry Frozen Sticks (+Essential Guide)

CookUnity vs Factor – Which Meal Service is Better for You?

CookUnity vs Factor – Which Meal Service is Better for You?

10 Best Meats for Healthy and Delicious Meal Prep

10 Best Meats for Healthy and Delicious Meal Prep

Your Essential Cheap/Budget Grocery List for Meal Prep (+ Tips)

Your Essential Cheap/Budget Grocery List for Meal Prep (+ Tips)
{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}