Meal Matchmaker is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

Magic Spoon Cereal Review: What’s so Magical About It?

Written By: Paul

Last Updated on December 23, 2021

Long gone are the good old childhood days when we started every morning with a bowl of crunchy cereal to get us going.

As an adult, you realize that eating sugar-packed cereal in the morning is not the best idea of a healthy and nutritious breakfast. It only makes you crash from empty carbs in the afternoon when you are supposed to be the most productive.

Greg Sewitz and Gabi Lewis, the co-founders of Magic Spoon, were craving that memorable childhood crunch in the morning. However, they wanted to avoid the spike of blood sugar and insulin levels and all health-related side effects of high sugar consumption.

After realizing there isn’t a healthy cereal box on the market, they experimented for a year and came with a unique formulation. This breakfast treat will allow you to enjoy the favorite American breakfast, completely guilt-free!

Magic Spoon Cereal At A Glance

  • Best Match For: Cereal-lovers seeking a protein-packed alternative that tastes just as good without the excess sugar.
  • Commitment Level: One-time purchase; Subscription (10% off)
  • AvailabilityEverywhere in the US
  • Value$39/case ($1.95/bowl); Shipping fees apply
  • Type: Ready-to-eat healthy gluten-free cereals

How Magic Spoon Cereal Works?

The company offers one-time or monthly delivery. One case contains four boxes, each with 7 servings of Magic Spoon’s delicious high-protein cereal.

You can choose between fruity, cinnamon, cocoa, blueberry, frosted, nutty, or a variety case. Each flavor comes in a standard case with 4 boxes, while the variety pack contains fruity, frosted, cocoa, and blueberry flavor.

Their newest addition, the nutty case, includes two boxes of peanut butter and honey nut cereal. However, it is sold out at the moment due to high demand.

Ordering is easy, and you can choose a subscription option where you’ll get a case of your choosing each month. You can manage your order or cancel at any time, which is super convenient. 

What You Can Expect From Your Meal

What everybody wants to know is whether Magic Spoon is as good as the cereal brands that were our childhood favorites. And the answer is – YES!

It is advertised as a high-protein, keto-friendly, low-carb, grain-free, gluten-free, soy-free, wheat-free delicious breakfast option with no artificial ingredients.

Each box contains 7 portions, with a nutrition label showing 11 grams of protein, 0 sugar, and 3 grams of net carbohydrates per bowl on average.

That is pretty impressive. But how did they manage to cut out all the bad stuff from cereal?

Firstly, except for the recognizable taste and crunch, Magic Spoon is nothing like traditional cereal. In fact, it better compares to energy bars and keto smoothies when we look at the composition and nutritional value.

The brand doesn’t add any refined sugar to their cereal. They use a natural sweetener blend made with sugars from monk fruits, stevia, and allulose.

Allulose is a naturally-occurring sugar found in things like maple syrup and figs. It provides a deliciously sweet taste, but it won’t spike your blood glucose levels thanks to the low glycemic impact.

Milk protein isolate and whey protein isolate boost the protein content and give a smooth texture.

The additions of high-oleic sunflower oil and avocado oil bring healthy fats into the whole equation.

Finally, tapioca starch, inulin from chicory root, and a pinch of salt are all it takes to make this delicious breakfast. The company doesn’t use any artificial sweeteners, flavors, colors, or preservatives.

You can expect everything you love about traditional cereal, without having to worry about high-sugar and low-protein meals that won’t keep you full until lunch.

Sample Meals

The Variety pack includes:

  • Fruity – Forget about Froot Loops, as the Fruity flavor offers that recognizable taste, but with a superior nutritious spin.
  • Frosted – If simplicity is your thing, you’ll love this formulation’s sweet, subtle taste with hints of vanilla and marshmallow.
  • Cocoa – A big fan of Cocoa Puffs? Then cocoa flavor should be your choice. It resembles a moderately sweet chocolate shake.
  • Blueberry – Your favorite berry flavor is now healthier than ever. And tastier!

Most cereal lovers will find a ¾ of a cup serving to be on the smaller side and will demolish two portions without a problem. So instead of the initial 28 servings, you may finish off your whole case in no time.


Once you place your order, it is processed within one business day.

Then your order is shipped via DHL or UPS, and you’ll receive a tracking number to follow the progress of your order.

Delivery is available throughout the United States, but unfortunately, there is no expedited shipping option.


Is Magic Spoon good?

It is more than good; it is fantastic! The brand offers a unique healthy twist on America’s favorite breakfast, and you’ll love it.

Which is better: Cereal School or Magic Spoon?

Both brands are excellent keto-friendly breakfast options. Nutrition-wise, either option will provide enough nutrients to start your day. Especially if you add some nuts and seeds to your Saturday morning bowl.

As long as taste goes, you will have to try both brands and decide for yourself. We give a slight edge to Magic Spoon.

What is Magic Spoon cereal made of?

Forget about grains as Magic Spoon’s formulation consists of milk proteins, monk fruit extract, stevia, allulose, chicory fiber, tapioca flour, and a pinch of salt. The brand highlights the use of all-natural ingredients with no artificial additives.

What is the best Magic Spoon flavor?

We are divided on the whole flavor topic. While some customers are excited about the cinnamon flavor that tastes like Cinnamon Toast Crunch, others prefer the cocoa flavor, and even the blueberry one.

The Nutty case has been particularly popular since the launch, and many people are raving about it. 

Does Magic Spoon actually taste good?

Yes, Magic Spoon is delicious. And because it has a high protein content, it can fill you up pretty well. It also has fewer carbs and is a much healthier cereal alternative.

Is Magic Spoon overpriced?

Well, it isn’t overpriced, considering that you get to eat cereal for breakfast without all the bad stuff in it. But the only way to purchase Magic Spoon cereal is to buy a case with four packs for $39. And that can be too much for some people.

Is Magic Spoon cereal FDA approved?

Yes, Magic Spoon cereal is approved by the FDA and safe to eat.

Is Magic Spoon cereal filling?

Yes, thanks to all the protein. With 11 grams per serving, you can eat it for breakfast or post-workout meals or as a snack. It is more filling than your standard cereal.

Which is better: Magic Spoon or Cereal School?

It all comes down to personal taste. However, some people prefer the taste and texture of Magic Spoon. In addition, it is more filling and more affordable.

Is Magic Spoon safe?

Yes, Magic Spoon is completely safe. The FDA and other third parties have reviewed it, and they all came to this conclusion.

Is Magic Spoon worth the price?

Yes, Magic Spoon is worth the price for all cereal lovers looking for a healthy alternative breakfast. It is tasty, has the right texture, and, more importantly, has no excessive amounts of sugar.

What are the ingredients in Magic Spoon cereal?

Magic Spoon is made with tapioca flour, milk and whey isolates, chicory root fiber, and coconut oil, with added allulose, monk fruit, and stevia.

How long does Magic Spoon last?

Magic Spoon cereal can last up to nine months on the shelf.

Magic Spoon Costs

Magic Spoon delivers cases with four 7 oz boxes of their low-carb cereal. Each box costs $39, and you can save 10% if you subscribe for regular orders. That’s around $1.95 per bowl, and there are also additional shipping fees based on the delivery location.

Pros and Cons

  • It’s way healthier than traditional cereal
  • 100% customer happiness guarantee
  • Available subscription service
  • Quick delivery nationwide
  • Some people have complained about the paste-like consistency after leaving it in milk for too long

Food for Thought

Magic Spoon offers an incredible cereal alternative for all those lovers of this classic American breakfast, who are looking for a healthier alternative. Their cereals come in a ring shape, with crunchy consistency, but airy enough so that you don’t feel like you are eating sand.

With 11g of proteins and 3g of net carbs per serving, it is more delicious and healthier than your traditional cereal. With a whimsical box design and a maze on the backside, it is perfect for people who like to keep occupied by looking at the packaging during breakfast.

Customer service and delivery are excellent, and there is a 100% customer happiness guarantee if you are not satisfied with their products for any reason.

Magic Spoon is perfect for all cereal-lovers who are following a keto diet. It may earn a special spot among your breakfast cereal options quickly, or you can use it as a healthy afternoon snack.

Magic Spoon Cereal offers one-time or monthly delivery to your door

Magic Spoon Cereal

  • It’s way healthier than traditional cereal
  • 100% customer happiness guarantee
  • Available subscription service
  • Quick delivery nationwide

Hi, I'm Paul. Welcome to my website! I, along with my cronies, are leveraging our years of working in the food industry to review meal and drink delivery services. We review. You eat happily ever after.

Related Posts:

Read These Next

Sun Basket vs Purple Carrot: Which is Best for You?

Sun Basket vs Purple Carrot: Which is Best for You?

Can You Meal Prep Steak? (Yes, Here’s How)

Can You Meal Prep Steak? (Yes, Here’s How)

How Long to Air Fry Frozen Sticks (+Essential Guide)

How Long to Air Fry Frozen Sticks (+Essential Guide)

CookUnity vs Factor – Which Meal Service is Better for You?

CookUnity vs Factor – Which Meal Service is Better for You?

10 Best Meats for Healthy and Delicious Meal Prep

10 Best Meats for Healthy and Delicious Meal Prep

Your Essential Cheap/Budget Grocery List for Meal Prep (+ Tips)

Your Essential Cheap/Budget Grocery List for Meal Prep (+ Tips)
{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}