Meal Matchmaker is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

Foodstirs Review: Here are all the Pros and Cons we Considered

Last Updated on December 23, 2021

Baking is fun, but it's not the most beginner-friendly hobby. It can be time-consuming, full of complex techniques, and when you review your final product it may not look anything like you hoped.

If you try to bake with children, you risk losing their attention halfway through or ending up with a small child hyped up on sugar. Foodstirs takes care of all of these issues, which is why it made our list of the best kids meal delivery services.

Foodstirs, a company founded by Sarah Michelle Gellar, Galit Laibow, and Greg Fleishman, is known as a "junk-free bakery." They provide baking mixes and ready-to-eat treats without preservatives or additives. Click here to read why we've rated them number one on our best dessert subscription box

As of 2020, Foodstirs ended their Foodstirs subscription box (also known as the Baker’s Club), which allowed people to subscribe to monthly baking kits. So we can no longer review it, but let's review all other aspects of the company.

Even though you can't get a baking subscription box, this Foodstirs review will tell you what you can expect when you purchase a baking kit from their online store.

See where Foodstirs ranks on our review of the best food subscription boxes

Foodstirs At A Glance

  • Best Match For: People looking for bite-size organic sweets, baking mixes, and baking kits with less sugar and no artificial ingredients.
  • Commitment Level: One-time orders; Subscription (5% off)
  • Availability: The continental US
  • Value: $5.99-$29.99/item; $7.99 shipping fee; Orders over $80 receive free shipping
  • Type: Ready-to-eat mini donuts, muffins, and brownie bites; organic baking mixes and exclusive baking kits

How Foodstirs Works

Actress Sarah Michelle Gellar founded Foodstirs in 2014 after wanting parents to have a way to have baked goods for their kids with clean ingredients. A review of Foodstirs shows that they use low sugar and fair-trade chocolate, and all of the ingredients are non-GMO and organic.

Here's a review of the types of Foodstirs products:

  • 1. Baking mixes such as Keto Chocolate Chip cookie mix
  • 2. Pre-packed donuts and Foodstirs brownies
  • 3. Exclusive baking kits

The Foodstirs baking subscription used to include a monthly delivery of one of the organic baking subscription kits. Now, everyone can order and review these products a la carte for a fun home project. Some of their baking kits include a Rainbow Pancake Kits, Donut Kit, Tropical Island Cupcake Kit, and a Mini Gingerbread House Kit.

If you're looking for something quicker, then review Foodstirs' large selection of organic baking mixes that you can prepare in minutes. These items include brownie mix, sugar cookies mix, coffee cake box mix, and more. Either way, a Foodstirs product makes for a fun activity with family or friends.

You can also find products from Foodstirs in a local grocery store such as Target or Whole Foods. It's one of the most popular cooking subscription boxes.

What You Can Expect from Your Meal

Whenever you order one of the Foodstirs baking kits, you are in for an exciting experience. The kits come with everything you need to get started: detailed instructions, baking tools, decorations, and dry ingredients.

For example, you know how every time you make cupcakes you end up with 1,000 leftover cupcake liners in your pantry? Well, Foodstirs will only send you the number you need. Their model streamlines the baking process and ensures that you don't have to shop for one-time ingredients that will just take up kitchen space later.

When your shipment arrives, you will need to review the directions and provide some of the wet ingredients yourself. Fortunately, you'll probably already have some of these things: milk, eggs, butter, water, and yogurt.

All you need to do is follow the detailed recipes, and you'll have no problem making restaurant-quality cookies, cake pops, and more. The best part is you don't have to feel guilty about eating two or three!

Sample Meals

When you review the company site, you can see exactly what will come in your organic baking kits.

If you want to recreate the Foodstirs dessert subscription box, you can order these dishes regularly. You could also pick a recipe to follow every month from the company website.

You can review the Foodstirs reviews for each product from others before you buy one.

Some examples of boxes are:

Unicorn Treat Pops

The Unicorn Cake Pops kit comes with plant-based food dyes and organic cake mix to make any customer feel like a pro baker. A review of the box includes:

  • a unicorn sticker sheet
  • unicorn sprinkles
  • an educational activity sheet
  • vanilla frosting mix
  • vanilla cake pop mix

Wildberry Pinwheel Cookies

This kit allows you to make pinwheels in fun colors, and it comes with:

  • sugar cookie mix
  • organic baking dye
  • a spatula set
  • a rolling pin
  • lemon wildberry flavor packet
  • special coupons


Foodstirs only ships to continental US addresses via USPS. FedEx, or UPS.

There is no shipping to P.O. boxes. When they offered the subscription box service, customers could expect their orders to ship on the 10th of the month.

Now, you should receive your stuff within 5 to 7 days.

You can also send an item as a gift to your loved ones.

Simply put their address as the shipping address and the package will arrive at their door. 

Foodstirs also gives different gift card options called "Bakery Bucks" that your recipient will get via email.

Once you place an order, you will get a review email with your tracking information.

If you pay the price for expedited shipping, you may get your thing within 3 to five business days.


Who owns Foodstirs?

Sarah Michelle Gellar began Foodstirs in California in 2014. Her mission was to provide a baking subscription and baking products that are easy to make and feature clean ingredients.

Are Foodstirs baking kits vegan?

All of the baking mixes are vegan except for one, which is part of the reason they have such positive Foodstirs reviews. Only some of the kits are vegan. However, you can contact customer service to find information about ways to substitute milk and eggs in the different recipes. Lastly, the kits are not gluten-free.

Where is Foodstirs?

Foodstirs is based in Santa Monica, California. The company was founded by Sarah Michelle Gellar, Greg Fleishman, and Galit Laibow with the goal of providing junk-free snacks for kids.

Is Foodstirs gluten free?

Yes, Foodstirs is completely gluten-free, low sugar, grain-free, low carb, and keto. All of the baking mixes are junk-free, organic, and kosher as well. You can satisfy your cravings without any of the bad stuff.

Foodstirs Costs

Based on the treats you select, you can expect to pay $5.99-$29.99 per item. There is also a $7.99 shipping fee, but you receive free delivery if your order exceeds $80. People who want to enjoy these sweets regularly can sign up for a subscription and receive a 5% discount.

Food for Thought

Sarah Michelle Gellar had the idea to create a junk-free bakery. Whether you want a pack of mini brownies or a baking project, the company has something for everyone. In review, though there is no subscription box, the results you get from your first order will make you ready to do it again.

The cool part about Foodstirs is how perfect it is for children over six years old. Additionally, you can share your Foodstirs creation with the company's online community as well as review the creations of other members.

Foodstirs treats are most compatible with people looking for organic sweets and a way to have a bit of fun in the kitchen.

Foodstirs baking subscription and delivery services


  • Comes with everything you need to bake, such as cookie cutters and other supplies
  • Offers a Keto chocolate chip mix
  • Available in select stores if you don't want to wait for shipping
  • The themes of the kits make them fun for all ages

Hi, I'm Paul. Welcome to my website! I, along with my cronies, are leveraging our years of working in the food industry to review meal and drink delivery services. We review. You eat happily ever after.

Related Posts:

Read These Next

Best Diwali Sweets Online

Best Diwali Sweets Online

Blue Apron Has Acknowledged that We Aren’t Truly Motivated to Labor

Blue Apron Has Acknowledged that We Aren’t Truly Motivated to Labor

Beginner’s Guide to the Nutritarian Diet

Beginner’s Guide to the Nutritarian Diet

Wild Diet: What is it and What Can You Eat?

Wild Diet: What is it and What Can You Eat?

Dubrow Diet: Benefits and Risks

Dubrow Diet: Benefits and Risks

What is Bob Harper’s Super Carb Diet?

What is Bob Harper’s Super Carb Diet?
{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}