Meal Matchmaker is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

November 16, 2020

Best Seafood Subscription Box
Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

It's hard to deny the thrill that comes from seeing restaurant-quality fish or shellfish on your dinner table. Wild caught seafood is a delicious meal choice packed with protein. However, it can be challenging to find good, fresh sea foods near you.

Seafood subscription boxes are the perfect way to get the freshest seafood delivered from the Atlantic to your door. You can satisfy your cravings for anything from tuna to bass to crab cakes without leaving home. With subscription boxes, folks get a hassle-free way to make amazing food every month.

We listed the best seafood subscription boxes below so that you can find the right seafood box for you.

Best Fish Subscriptions & Seafood Delivery Services

1 - Vital Choice (Editor's Choice)

  • Best Match For: People looking for a large selection of sustainably caught seafood, organic foods, marine-sourced supplements, and more.
  • Commitment Level: One time purchase; Subscription
  • Availability: All 50 states
  • Value: $129-$199/month for subscriptions; Free shipping to the continental US on orders over $99
  • Type: Frozen fish, meat, and seafood, canned fish, organic foods, and dietary supplements

Vital Choice offers monthly seafood subscription boxes where you can get sustainably-caught seafood. 

Vital Box is their monthly curated box full of sustainable wild seafood that is shipped in an eco friendly insulated box with free shipping.

With Vital Choice, you can choose from three different subscription boxes:

  • wild salmon box
  • wild wish box
  • wild seafood box

The boxes vary in product offerings and recipe-ready portions but the whichever box you with, you will have plenty of food to last you every month.

Vital Choice seafood subscriptions and delivery services


  • Sustainable seafood that is Marine Stewardship Council certified.
  • Great options for different diets, including paleo, gluten-free, and keto.
  • Portions of salmon, tuna, or whitefish are recipe-ready.
  • Pay as you go, so no surprise charges or fees.


  • You cannot change content of your subscription boxes.

2 - LobsterAnywhere 

  • Best Match For: People searching for the freshest premium-quality lobsters and seafood from Maine, surf and turf dinners, lobster chowders, and more.
  • Commitment Level: People searching for the freshest premium-quality lobsters and seafood from Maine, surf and turf dinners, lobster chowders, and more.
  • Availability: The contiguous US (including some parts of Alaska and Hawaii)
  • Value: Starting at $29.99/portion; Shipping starts at $29
  • Type: Premium fresh lobsters, seafood, ready-to-eat soups, and gourmet surf and turf packages

True to its name, LobsterAnywhere sends its products from the United States lobster capital—Maine. 

You will not only get lobster here; they also deliver cooked lobster meat, lobster rolls, New England clam chowder, bisque, and lobster tails along with much, MUCH more.  

And get this... they even ship LIVE LOBSTERS! 

They deliver lobster to just about every state in USA. 

LobsterAnywhere delivers fresh lobster at your door


  • Get a gourmet surf and turf package for any event or dinner.
  • Lobsters are guaranteed to be of high quality.
  • Shipping is quick and easy all year round.
  • Join the rewards program to save money.


  • LobsterAnywhere is not a monthly subscription service.

3 - SizzleFish 

  • Best Match For: Families looking to bring more sustainably sourced seafood and fish into their diets without breaking the budget.
  • Commitment Level: Subscription
  • Availability: The contiguous US (No Alaska or Hawaii)
  • Value: $7.99-$8.99/serving; Free shipping
  • Type: Wild-caught or farm-raised frozen fish and seafood

SizzleFish ships subscription boxes of wild caught fish and shellfish to your door in vacuum-sealed packaging. There are three boxes to choose from, and each box contains a variety of products.

With the SizzleFish prime subscription, you can choose from crab cakes, wild sockeye salmon, sea scallops, and more in your subscription boxes.

The best part about SizzleFish is that you can customize your own subscription boxes. Then, you get 14 cuts of your fish delivered and ready to cook.

SizzleFish delivers vacuum-sealed packaging sea foods products


  • Can order as a one-time seafood box or get a subscription.
  • Most options for fish species.
  • Fast shipping at no charge for subscription boxes.
  • Customers can easily cancel or change their subscription boxes.


  • Some fish species are farmed.

4 - Fulton Fish Market

Best match for: Environmentally conscious consumers.

The Fulton Fish Market subscription boxes are called The Fish Drop.

Your shipment comes directly from fishers on regulated waters in an NYC market. This company delivers all sorts of catches and subscription boxes to restaurants and chefs around the country.

They have many subscription boxes to pick from at great prices. Get just two servings or even eight or nine.

You can also choose a delivery scheduled at your convenience: weekly, biweekly, or monthly.

Fulton Fish Market delivers all sorts of catches and subscriptions boxes


  • Get cooking tips and recipes with your subscription boxes.
  • Seafood products are never frozen; your purchase comes in safe gel packs.
  • Full transparency about harvest practices and fisheries.
  • Add on shellfish servings to our box a la carte.


  • Seafood delivery service only applies to orders in the U.S.

5 - The Crab Place 

  • Best Match For: Seafood lovers searching for domestically sourced live or freshly-caught crabs and seafood.
  • Commitment Level: No commitments - Order at any time
  • Availability: All 50 states
  • Value: Prices start at around $20/lb of wild-caught salmon, and go up depending on what you choose; Shipping fees start at $19.95
  • Type: Maryland crabs, seafood, fish, kitchen tools, seasonings, and more

Subscription boxes from The Crab Place come from the Maryland coast to your doorstep. You can order live or steamed crabs no matter where you are in the United States. Their subscription boxes selection includes:

  • crab cakes
  • crab meat
  • lobster tails
  • king crab legs
  • oysters
  • shrimp

To ensure the best results, The Crab Place shipments include only same-day catches. As a customer, you have the option to subscribe to the VIP club to enjoy free shipping.

The Crab Place services offers everything crab-related meals


  • Seafood inventory comes from docks in the Chesapeake Bay region.
  • Access online recipes for chowders and more.
  • Product satisfaction guarantee.
  • Newsletter has information on deals and events.


  • Some live crabs may die in transit.

6 - Wild Alaskan Company

Best match for: Fans of wild caught seafood.

When it comes to quality seafood, you don't always get what you want at your local grocery stores.

Wild Alaskan Company subscription boxes offer all types of meats and plans.

You can choose a white fish plan, get sockeye salmon, or pick the combo plan subscription boxes.

These subscription boxes arrive at your door in sustainable packaging with minimal plastic, so they don't hurt the planet.

The box is made of recyclable materials, and the insulation foam is compostable.

Wild Alaskan Company offer all types of meats and plans for you


  • Flash-frozen in a freezer straight from the fishing vessel.
  • Deliveries in subscription boxes remain cold for a long time.
  • Delivered seafood is individually-wrapped.
  • All fish for the subscription boxes come from the Pacific Northwest or Alaska.


  • Subscription boxes are only monthly or bimonthly.

7 - Maine Lobster Now

Best match for: Someone looking for a comprehensive, one-time delivery.

Maine Lobster Now is a company located in Portland, Maine. The founder wants to provide fresh seafood experiences and subscription boxes to people who do not live in a coastal area.

The products in your order come directly from fishermen in Maint's local seafood industry.

Maine Lobster Now also offers gourmet options for meats, soups, and desserts.

At market price, you can add an assortment of items to your box such as swordfish, tuna, and snapper.

They also sell handy supplies to help you eat and prepare your lobster.

Maine Lobster Now  provide fresh seafood experiences and subscription boxes to people


  • A professional lobster tank ensures amazing flavor.
  • Easy to gift to friends or family members.
  • Plenty of seafood choices delivered to your door.
  • Delivery comes on a date that you specify.


  • Need to order well in advance to make sure your food arrives on time.

8 - Lobster Gram 

Best match for: People who want minimal preparation.

Also from Maine, Lobster Gram is the perfect place to find everything you need for a phenomenal meal.

You can get black cod, halibut, sides, beef, mussels, and other add-ons for yourself or a friend.

Lobster Gram also has helpful cooking guides and videos if you are new to preparing lobster.

Lobster Gram delivers fresh or frozen packages to your door


  • You can order beautiful gift subscription boxes.
  • Choose your delivery date as early as months in advance.
  • Packages can come fresh or frozen.
  • Share your subscription boxes when you order a meal for two.


  • There are no recurring subscription boxes available.

9 - Ocean Box 

Best match for: Flexible shipping options.

Ocean Box gets subscription boxes to you within three days of the seafood catch.

You can choose the delivery date that works for you so that you don't have to worry about missing your delivery. You can easily email their customer service team if you have any issues with your boxes.

Get an idea of how to use your fish selections from your favorite recipes for some at-home luxury dining.

Ocean Box offers flexible shipping options for you


  • Online blog features health tips, an article page, cooking links, and posts.
  • Rising in popularity as one of the best subscription boxes.
  • Offers several plans with no-cost shipping.
  • Get as many servings as you need for your household.


  • May not deliver to all areas in the US.

10 - Sea to Table 

Best match for: Those seeking transparency with their food source.

If you feel limited in your seafood choices at home, Sea To Table subscription boxes are a perfect way to solve that problem.

Every case of fish comes with a label, so you know exactly where it's from.

All of their subscription boxes come from American fisheries, and it's cool to see exactly which boat caught your snack.

Sea to Table best meal delivery services and subscription boxes


  • One of the best meal delivery services and subscription boxes.
  • Pre-portioned so that it's ready to cook and serve.
  • None of the meals have hormones or antibiotics.
  • Choose from different subscription boxes or get a one-time purchase.


  • There is a 25.00 pound order minimum.

11 - Sitka Salmon Shares

Best match for: Community-oriented foodies.

Sitka subscription boxes come from one of the best places to find king salmon: Southeast Alaska. The cool part about this seafood service is that a collective of local fishermen own it and get a share of the commission.

When you become a member of Sitka, you get a share of that catch from a fishing family every month.

Sitka Salmon Shares seafood services delivers to your door


  • The fish in the subscription boxes is blast frozen to lock in freshness.
  • Choose from four different size cases for subscription boxes.
  • Great reviews on various social media platforms.
  • Form a relationship with a fishing family in Alaska.


  • The amount of seafood in the subscription boxes varies each month.

Subscription Boxes - The Difference Between Fresh and Frozen

When you look through subscription boxes, you will see different methods of delivery. The truth is, many people have their own opinion on the best way to ship fish around the world.

Fresh fish isn't always better than frozen. Flash-freezing allows fish companies to maintain their taste and freshness until they reach your table. If you live far from a coast or lake, the "fresh" fish in your grocery store was probably frozen.


Where to Buy Fresh Seafood Near Me?

If you aren't ready for subscription boxes, check your local grocer or market for fresh food. When you do, be sure to ask questions about the origin and freshness of the food.

Where to Buy Fresh Fish?

When buying seafood, you can look for seafood delivery near me or check out one of the many subscription boxes above. Some tips for ensuring freshness are:

  • Only use seafood that arrived cool to the touch.
  • Check for discoloration and odors.
  • Check the rating for the service and make sure the location has a license.

Where to Buy Seafood?

Seafood is a thing that you do not want to buy from just anywhere. It's best to buy it from a reputable and sustainable source. Find out the origins of your food subscription boxes, and note whether it is farm-raised or wild-caught.

What is Our #1 Recommended Seafood Subscription?

Seafood is a good source of omega 3 fatty acids, and you want to integrate it into your diet. If you're looking for delivery near me seafood, then you should try one of the above subscription boxes to introduce a new type of convenience into your kitchen.

We chose Vital Choice as our number one subscription because of its ease of use and phenomenal options. In addition to premium wild seafood, you can get chicken, seasonings, and even supplements. There are so many ways to alter these subscription boxes to make sure they meet your needs.

Vital Choice seafood subscriptions and delivery services

Vital Choice

Our #1 Recommendation

  • Sustainable seafood that is Marine Stewardship Council certified.
  • Great options for different diets, including paleo, gluten-free, and keto.
  • Portions of salmon, tuna, or whitefish are recipe-ready.
  • Pay as you go, so no surprise charges or fees.

Read These Next

What Are the Best Cake Delivery Services?
Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

Sizzlefish Review: What’s the Scoop on This Sustainably Sourced Seafood Delivery Service?

The CookBook App Review: Everything You Need to Know

What Are the Best CBD Coffee Delivery Services?
Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

Our Review of Addictive Wellness and Their Sugar-free, Gluten-free, Vegan, and Paleo Chocolates with Elixir Blends

Bota Box Wine Review: Do These Low Carb, Low Calories Wines Taste Good? Our Honest Review