Meal Matchmaker is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

Top 4 Pizza of the Month Club Subscription Box (My Favorites)

Written By: Paul

#2nd Best choice

Amazing Clubs pizza delivery service

Amazing Clubs

#3rd Best Choice

Great Clubs of America Pizza delivery service

Great Clubs of America

#4th Best Choice

Great Clubs of America Pizza delivery service

Flying Noodle

If there’s one thing that unites people, it’s pizza. This legendary Italian food phenomenon has made it into the hearts of Americans for countless generations. Did you know that over 3 billion pizzas are sold in the States every year?

As a pizza lover, the prospect of a monthly subscription sounds like a dream. 

Fresh and delicious pizzas delivered straight to my door every month? Sign me up! 

Today I’m going to rank the best Pizza of the Month Club services you’ll find. Discover which pizza subscription club is perfect for you!

How Did We Select the Best Pizza of the Month Subscription Boxes?

  1. Quality and taste: First, I looked at the overall quality of the pizzas. I considered factors such as the freshness of the ingredients and how well the flavors were balanced in my mouth.

  2. Variations and customization: I also looked at the ways you can customize your box. Can I make them vegetarian or allergy-friendly?

  1. Packaging and delivery: Another aspect is the delivery range of the services. When it comes down to it, we all want a pizza service that delivers to our door! 

  2. Pricing: And finally, how much does the subscription cost? I looked at the value you’re getting for each box, and compared each service.

The Best Pizza of the Month Club Subscription Boxes in 2023

Now that I’ve laid out the criteria, let’s get into the rankings! 

1. Goldbelly (Editor's Choice)

  • Best Match For: food enthusiasts who want a marketplace that can offer them exclusive and gourmet dishes, sweets, meats, meal kits, pizzas, and pretty much anything food-related
  • Pricing: $89.95 per month
  • Availability: All 50 states
  • Pizza Variety: four pizzas per box from plenty of staple pizzerias across the country!
  • Commitment Level: one time orders, 3, 6, 9, or 12-month subscriptions and can also be sent as a gift
  • Ordering Process: choose your subscription duration, enter your details, and wait to receive your pizza goodness!
  • My Rating: 4.5/5
Goldbelly Pizza delivery service

Overview

With Goldbelly monthly subscription services, I no longer need to choose between cheesy and cheeseless, pan pizza and pepperoni, thin crust, and thick cornicione – I can have it all!

Goldbelly Seasonal Club sends you a monthly pizza subscription box with enough pizza to serve 4 people (though I don't blame you if you eat it all on your own because... pizza!). 

This is the perfect way to get out of your pizza rut and try something new. After all, that’s what life’s all about!

The pizzas are prepared fresh and delivered straight to your doorstep. I liked having the opportunity to receive unique pizzas from the country’s best pizzerias. 

Why do I like It?

What I particularly like about Goldbelly is the number of subscription plans they offer! 

I have the choice between subscriptions from 3 months up to 12 months. They also offer a one-time order, so you can try it before committing.

Pros and Cons

PROS

  • A selection of different pizzas every month
  • Choose your desired subscription length – 3 to 12 months
  • Pizzas are flash frozen – each frozen pizza can be stored for up to a month
  • Ready to eat in 15 minutes

Cons

  • No customizations or adaptations for allergies
  • Pre-paid subscriptions can’t be canceled - you have to remember to manually cancel them.

2. Amazing Clubs

  • Best Match For: Anyone wanting a hand-picked selection of pizzas, as well as options for other gifts
  • Pricing: Depends on the subscription, and you can choose to pay either in full or per delivery. Pricing starts at $74.95 for 3 months
  • Availability: everywhere in the US
  • Pizza Variety: three deep-dish Chicago-style pizzas
  • Commitment Level: 3, 6, and 12-month subscription
  • Type: gift of the month clubs
  • My Rating: 4.5/5
Amazing Clubs pizza delivery service

Overview

Amazing Clubs is one of the excellent monthly clubs that send you a selection of three Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas every month. 

The pizzas are crowned with the finest, mouth-watering toppings and are baked with all-natural ingredients and the highest quality products. Each pizza has to go through a thorough examination by their taste-testing panel before it is released.

Select between a 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month subscription where the price per pizza gets successively lower.

Why do I like It?

The best part about this service for me is their customer-service guarantee. 

Their “They’ll Love It!” guarantee sends you a new product or complete refund if you’re not 100% satisfied. 

They’ll also offer to pay you the difference if you find a lower price elsewhere. Talk about good service!

Pros and Cons

PROS

  • Baked with all-natural, high-quality ingredients
  • Money back if you're not satisfied
  • Flexible subscription length
  • Carefully selected pizzas by a panel of taste-testing experts

Cons

  • Not catering to allergies or vegans

3. Great Clubs of America

  • Best Match For: People wanting unique, hand-crafted pizzas delivered straight to their door
  • Pricing: $55.78/month + FREE Shipping
  • Availability: the continental US 
  • Pizza Variety: three Chicago deep-dish pizzas
  • Commitment Level: 2-12 month memberships
  • My Rating: 4/5
Great Clubs of America Pizza delivery service

Overview

Fancy an artisan pizza with a hand-crafted crust? Then look no further! 

Great Clubs of America offers a selection of three gourmet, deep-dish pizzas every shipment. 

Each pizza is hand-crafted and topped with rich, original sauces, and the dishes are baked by a family-owned pizzeria in Chicago that’s been in the industry since 1947.

Each month, you’ll receive a surprise delivery with three of the best pizzas out there! This company has had a variety of types on the menu before, which I also enjoyed a lot. 

Some examples of previous selections I can happily recommend are varieties with Italian beef, eggplants, meatballs, Thai chicken, and crispy vegetables.

All the pizzas shipped arrive frozen; you can keep them for up to a month in the freezer.

Why do I like It?

What I like about Great Clubs of America is the freshness of their food. Every pizza is crafted with fresh ingredients – none of that processed stuff! 

The pizzas are hand-picked monthly by a chef to ensure you’re getting all the good ones.

Pros and Cons

PROS

  • Locally sourced ingredients of finest quality
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Free shipping on all orders
  • Flexible subscription frequency

Cons

  • You don’t get to choose what pizzas you get

4. Flying Noodle

  • Best Match For: anyone looking for a good variety of deep-dish style pizzas
  • Pricing: varied, starting from $74.95/month for three months
  • Delivery Area: the continental US
  • Pizza Variety: three deep-dish Chicago-style pizzas
  • Commitment Level: subscription-based, either 3, 6, or 12 months or seasonal.
  • My Rating: 4/5

Overview

Feeling like a luscious, deep-dish pizza baked with the best ingredients that are all-natural? Flying Noodle knows the deep-dish pizza game inside out!

Members can choose to sign up for a total of 3, 6, or 12 months with this club.

You can also gift a Flying Noodle subscription to someone you like (if they don't like you back yet, they will!). 

If you're sending a subscription as a gift, you can send a gift announcement using U.S. Mail or email. You can also print your gift announcement directly from your computer. I think it's an excellent solution as a last-minute present!

Why do I like It?

What I like most about Flying Noodle’s subscription box is that you get three unique pizzas every month. 

Each pizza has three servings and is frozen to preserve its fresh flavors. Get ready to find your new favorite!

Pros and Cons

PROS

  • Hand-selected pizzas with premium, all-natural ingredients
  • Frozen to consume at your convenience
  • Free shipping on all orders
  • Monthly newsletter with information and fun pizza facts

Cons

  • Customizations of shipments are not possible

Which Pizza of the Month Club Subscription Box is the Best?

For me, the best option for a pizza of the month club subscription box would have to be Goldbelly. 

They really stand out when it comes to the range you can choose from, and have the most options of the places I’ve tried. Have fun digging into your pies!

Bottom Line

If you're a genuine pizza lover like me, a monthly pizza club will be your next dream come true. Get the best of deep-dish pizza from the finest pizzerias in the nation! With a pizza club, you can sit back and relax while embarking on delicious pizza expeditions filled with flavors from Chicago deep-dish to New York-style varieties. 

With the help of express pizza post, you can have it all from the comfort of your own home. No more having to pass by the local pizza place to get your appetite satisfied! You can also use the pizza subscription as a perfect gift for your loved ones - you can be sure that the gift recipients will be over the moon with such a treat.

Combine with monthly clubs for other kinds of food and services, such as cooking classes, to feed into your love for all things food and drinks. There's virtually a club for everything! Regular shipments of food items from a company of your choice give you a chance to discover new favorites to indulge in. Cheers to that!

Goldbelly Pizza delivery service

Goldbelly

Our #1 Recommendation

  • A selection of different pizzas every month
  • Choose your desired subscription length – 3 to 12 months
  • Pizzas are frozen – can be stored up to a month
  • Ready to eat in 15 minutes

Hi, I'm Paul. Welcome to my website! I, along with my cronies, are leveraging our years of working in the food industry to review meal and drink delivery services. We review. You eat happily ever after.

Read These Next


Sun Basket vs Purple Carrot: Which is Best for You?

Sun Basket vs Purple Carrot: Which is Best for You?

Can You Meal Prep Steak? (Yes, Here’s How)

Can You Meal Prep Steak? (Yes, Here’s How)

How Long to Air Fry Frozen Sticks (+Essential Guide)

How Long to Air Fry Frozen Sticks (+Essential Guide)

CookUnity vs Factor – Which Meal Service is Better for You?

CookUnity vs Factor – Which Meal Service is Better for You?

10 Best Meats for Healthy and Delicious Meal Prep

10 Best Meats for Healthy and Delicious Meal Prep

Your Essential Cheap/Budget Grocery List for Meal Prep (+ Tips)

Your Essential Cheap/Budget Grocery List for Meal Prep (+ Tips)