Meal Matchmaker is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

January 9, 2021

What are the Best Pizza of the Month Services?
Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

#2nd Best choice

Amazing Clubs pizza delivery service

Amazing Clubs

#3rd Best Choice

Great Clubs of America Pizza delivery service

Great Clubs of America

There are some things that people either love or hate – and there are other things that people love. Like pizza. This legendary Italian food phenomenon has made it into the hearts of the Americans for generations now. Did you know that 3 billion pizzas are sold in the States every year?!

Here, we list the four best Pizza of the Month services, ensuring you'll get your monthly dose of the finest flavors and toppings without having to leave your couch. Find out which pizza club is the perfect match for you! 

Our Top Pizza of the Month Services

1. Goldbelly (Editor's Choice)

  • Best Match For: Food enthusiasts who want a marketplace that can offer them exclusive and gourmet dishes, sweets, meats, meal kits, pizzas, and pretty much anything food-related.
  • Commitment Level: One-time orders; 3, 6, 9, or 12 month subscriptions
  • Availability: All 50 states
  • Value: Prices and shipping fees vary depending on select items
  • Type: A curated online marketplace of the best gourmet foods from small shops and restaurants across the nation.

With Goldbelly monthly subscription services, you no longer need to choose between cheesy and cheeseless, pan pizza and pepperoni, thin crust and thick cornicione – you can have it all!

Goldbelly sends you a monthly pizza subscription box serving 4 people (though we don't blame you if you eat it all on your own because... pizza!).

You have the choice between subscriptions from 3 months up to 12 months. Pizzas are prepared fresh and delivered from the nation's top pizzerias directly to your doorstep. That way, ingredients take a shorter path between the field and your fingertips.

This club is the perfect way of getting out of your pizza rut and get to try new and exciting flavors – after all, that's what life's all about!

Goldbelly Pizza delivery service

PROS

  • A selection of different pizzas every month
  • Choose your desired subscription length – 3 to 12 months
  • Pizzas are frozen – can be stored up to a month
  • Ready to eat in 15 minutes

Cons

  • No customizations or adaptations for allergies

2. Amazing Clubs

  • Best Match For: Anyone looking for a fantastic selection of gift of the month clubs that allow you to give out unique subscriptions with premium products people will surely enjoy.
  • Commitment Level: Subscription
  • Availability: Everywhere in the US
  • Value: You can sign up for monthly delivery of beer for $42.95, wines for $45.95, bacon for $49.95, chocolate for $35.95, and many other gift of the month clubs. Shipping is free to the contiguous US.
  • Type: Gift of the month clubs

Amazing Clubs sends you a selection of three deep-dish pizzas of Chicago style every month. The pizzas are crowned with the finest, mouth-watering toppings and are baked with all-natural ingredients. Each pizza has to go through thorough tests by their taste-testing panel before it is released.

Amazing Clubs has one of the most generous happy customer-guarantees: their "They'll Love It!" guarantee sends you a new product or complete refund if you're not 100% satisfied. Plus, if you find the same products at a lower price somewhere on the internet, they pay you the difference as compensation.

Select between a 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month subscription where the price per pizza gets successively lower. 

Amazing Clubs pizza delivery service

PROS

  • Baked with all-natural, high-quality ingredients
  • Money back if you're not satisfied
  • Flexible subscription length
  • Carefully selected pizzas by panel of taste-testing experts

Cons

  • Not catering to allergies or vegans

3. Great Clubs of America

  • Best Match For: People who always want to have an option of gifting exclusive hand-picked cigars, flowers, wines, beer, chocolate, and more through unique gift of the month clubs.
  • Commitment Level: 2-12 month memberships
  • Availability: The continental US
  • Value: $34.95-$64.95/month; Free shipping
  • Type: The ultimate Gift of the Month Club with flexible membership

Fancy an artisan pizza with a hand-crafted crust? Then look no further! Every month, Great Clubs of America ships you three deep-dish, delicious 9" Chicago style pizzas topped with rich, original sauces. A family-owned pizzeria in Chicago – that has been in the industry since 1947 – bakes the dish pizzas with quality ingredients that are locally sourced.

You get a surprise delivery with three of the best pizzas out there. This company has had a variety of types on the menu before. Some examples of previous selections are varieties with Italian beef, eggplants, meatballs, Thai chicken, and crispy vegetables.
Members can customize the subscription frequency: every month, every other month, or every 3 months. Plus, choose between subscription options of 2 up to 12 months.

Pizzas arrive frozen – you can keep them for up to a month in the freezer.

Great Clubs of America Pizza delivery service

PROS

  • Locally sourced ingredients of finest quality
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Free shipping on all orders
  • Flexible subscription frequency

Cons

  • Not possible to customize your orders

4. Flying Noodle

Feeling for a luscious, deep-dish pizza baked with the best ingredients that are all-natural? Flying Noodle knows the deep-dish pizza game inside out.

Your local pizza parlor is at risk when you've tried their monthly subscription! Don't say we didn't warn you.

With this club, you receive a package of three Chicago-style pizzas per month, where each pizza has three servings.

You get a variety of new, exciting pizzas each month – get ready to discover new favorites! Pizzas are instantly frozen to preserve the flavors. You can store them in the freezer for up to a month.

Members can choose to sign up for a total of 3, 6, or 12 months with this club.

You can also gift a Flying Noodle subscription to someone you like (if they don't like you back yet, they will!).

PROS

  • Hand-selected pizzas with premium, all-natural ingredients
  • Frozen to consume at your convenience
  • Free shipping on all orders
  • Monthly club newsletter with information and fun facts about pizzas

Cons

  • Customizations of shipments not possible

FAQS

What is the best Pizza of the Month club?

Great Clubs of America has been in the industry since 1947 and thus has an extensive savoir-faire that goes into each pizza. They have, just like Amazing Clubs, a money-back guarantee if you're not happy with your delivery. Goldbelly, on the other hand, is a club with the exciting concept of letting you try out different pizzerias. Flying Noodle offers free shipping.

Is there a Pizza of the Month Club catering to allergies?

At the time of writing this, none of the pizza clubs offered the option to adapt to allergies and diets. Some of the pizzas are vegetarian – but no club promises a certain number of veggie options. Check the website of the company of your choice for a list of allergens.

Do the month clubs for pizza offer other things as well?

Yes! Some of them offer pies, such as Goldbelly and Amazing Clubs – the latter one also offers wine. Order different types of wines through your club membership to enjoy with your favorite deep dish pizza. Fun fact: Goldbelly also has a variety of products and services that you can order with your pizza, such as cooking classes, vegan sweets, and seafood.

Bottom Line

A month club for pizza is the dream for the pizza lover. Get the best of deep-dish pizza from the finest pizzerias of the nation! With a pizza club, you can sit back and relax and while embarking on delicious pizza expeditions filled with flavors from Chicago deep-dish to New York-style varieties – all from the comfort of your own home. No more having to pass by the local pizza place to get your appetite satisfied!

Combine with month clubs for other kinds of food and services such as cooking classes, to feed into your love for all things food and drinks. There's virtually a club for everything! Regular shipments of food items from a company of your choice give you the chance to discover new favorites to indulge in. Cheers to that!

Goldbelly Pizza delivery service

Goldbelly

Our #1 Recommendation

  • A selection of different pizzas every month
  • Choose your desired subscription length – 3 to 12 months
  • Pizzas are frozen – can be stored up to a month
  • Ready to eat in 15 minutes

Read These Next


Friendsgiving: What is it and What do you Eat?

Friendsgiving: What is it and What do you Eat?

Heritage Turkeys: Do They Even Taste Better?

Heritage Turkeys: Do They Even Taste Better?

Why do we Eat Pumpkin Pie on Thanksgiving?

Why do we Eat Pumpkin Pie on Thanksgiving?

Sunbasket Review: Here’s Everything you Need to Know

Sunbasket Review: Here’s Everything you Need to Know

Why do we Eat Turkey on Thanksgiving?

Why do we Eat Turkey on Thanksgiving?

The Best Food Advent Calendars

The Best Food Advent Calendars