Meal Matchmaker is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

November 16, 2020

Best Mail Order Steaks
Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

If you are looking for an easy way to order steak online, but you don’t want to sacrifice quality, read on and find your favorite mail-order steaks.

These delicious cuts are perfect for a Sunday meal, but if you don’t have the time, skill, or an option to cook a perfect steak at your home, don’t worry. You won’t even have to google “best steaks near me” searching for a decent restaurant, as many butcher shops now do meats delivery and we've noted the best nationwide delivery services! 

Best Mail Order Steaks and Subscriptions Overview

1 - Snake River Farms (Editor's Choice)

Best match for: Top-quality American Wagyu beef and Kurobota pork lovers.

Snake River Farms is a premium meat provider from Idaho, offering top-quality beef and pork cuts to customers all over America. From tender filet mignon, prime rib, ribeye, and ground beef, to brisket – Snake River Farms provides an excellent selection of fine quality meats.

Their American Wagyu is a must-try for all steak lovers out there. American Wagyu is created by crossbreeding the Japanese purebred Wagyu with Angus cattle breeds, which results in a beautifully marbled meat full of flavor.

Instead of using the USDA Prime beef quality assessment scale, Snake River Farms uses the Japanese Beef Marbling Standard (BMS), specially created to capture the superior quality. The quality is graded on a 1-12 scale, and the company explains that the highest Prime designation meats on the USDA scale, usually fall in a 4 to 5 range.

In contrast, Black Grade rates as 6 or above on the BMS, while Gold Grade stands at 9 and above, making it one of the finest quality meats in the US.

Snake River Farms provides premium meats

PROS

  • A wide selection of cuts with bulk buying options
  • Award-winning premium quality American Wagyu 
  • All meat is wet-aged for 21+ days
  • Highest level of food safety practices

Cons

  • The company doesn’t offer free shipping

2 - Holy Grail Steaks

Best for: Anyone looking to try ultra-rare grade A5 Japanese Kobe beef.

What happens when a bunch of steak nerds with decades of experience in the greatest steakhouses, pastures, abattoirs, and butcher shops get together? You get a premier mail-order steak company with the highest quality cuts.

Holy Grail Steaks wanted more from a steak, which is why they became a certified Japanese Wagyu importer. They included an exceptional grade A5 Kobe beef, and a fine selection of American Wagyu, certified Akaushi, Australian Wagyu, and Prime Black Angus.

Holy Grail Steaks is a premier mail-order steak company with the highest quality cuts

PROS

  • Finest quality certified Japanese Wagyu 
  • 150 items of high-quality beef
  • 100% grass-fed and mostly grass-fed beef options
  • Safe packaging on dry ice with environmentally friendly materials

Cons

  • Some customers reported problems with the delivery system

3 - Chicago Steak Company

Best for: People who appreciate traditional dry-aging methods.

Chicago has a long tradition of high-quality meats, dating back to 1865 and the founding of the Union Stock Yard.

Chicago Steak Company has continued that tradition, as they offer Mid-West raised USDA Prime beef, considered as one of the most incredible steaks you can buy.

The company focuses on the whole process from raising cattle, hand-selecting, trimming, and using old-world meat aging methods that add a unique aroma to their meat.

You can see the results in beautiful marbling, tenderness, and robust flavor of each steak.

Chicago Steak Company delivers high quality meat products

PROS

  • Superior quality USDA Prime beef
  • Traditional wet and dry-aging techniques
  • A wide selection of meats that extend beyond beef
  • Several delivery options

Cons

  • The company doesn’t offer a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee

4 - FarmFoods

Best for: People who want to know where their meat comes from.

Inspired by how our ancestors used to get meat, FarmFoods has decided that we can do better than mass-produced, industrialized meats.

The company offers a variety of grass-fed beef options, as well as other meats like pork, pasture-raised chicken, lamb, seafood, lamb, and even elk.

Farm Foods best meat delivery services

PROS

  • You always know where your meat comes from
  • A wide selection of meats
  • Free delivery for orders over 10 pounds
  • Packaging with enough dry ice that your delivered meat remains frozen for up to 12 hours

Cons

  • Some reviews complain about the customer service quality

5 - Mr. Steak

Best for: Steak and adventure lovers.

Mick Sully, aka Mr. Steak, is a Chicago-native grill master and adventurer.

His love for a good barbecue and outdoors has set him on an adventure to create Mr. Steak website, where he offers high-quality meats, grills, accessories, as well as tips on how to improve your meat game.

Mr. Steak’s beef is sourced from ranches that supply top restaurants in the United States.

With pasture-raised cattle and grain-fed finishing touch to add the highest levels of marbling, you will surely enjoy Mr. Steak’s cuts. 

Mr. Steak supply meat products

PROS

  • High-quality American raised beef
  • You can order grills, accessories, and even seasoning
  • Biodegradable packaging and zero carbon emission shipping to ensure maximum sustainability
  • Meal donation program for helping Colorado community

Cons

  • Slightly limited selection

6 - Omaha Steaks

Best for: People looking to get everything they need for dinner in one place.

You had probably heard of Omaha Steaks, as they have a long history dating back to 1917 when the company was established. Even though they started as a brick and mortar butcher shop, they started offering steak deliveries to your door in the 1950s.

The company has an incredible selection ranging from dry-aged Wagyu cuts, Angus beef, pork, seafood, to appetizers, sides, desserts, and even wine. 

Omaha Steaks wide variety selections & gift packages

PROS

  • Biggest meat and foods selection out of all online meat purveyors
  • Incredibly easy ordering process
  • Long tradition with meal delivery
  • Omaha Steak reviews are buzzing

Cons

  • They could add more flexibility to minimum ordering items for certain products

7 - DeBragga

Best for: Anyone looking to enjoy naturally raised filet mignon steaks.

This New York-based butcher has been around since the early 1920s, and it’s been a reliable supplier of some of the 5-star Michelin restaurants.

DeBragga offers a wide selection of meats for everyday and special occasions. From grain and grass-fed Angus beef wet or dry-aged to perfection, to international Wagyu steaks with exceptional taste and silkiness, you can find your perfect steak at DeBragga.

DeBragga excellent steak selection choices

PROS

  • Incredible selection including beef, pork, poultry, lamb, veal, and game meats
  • American, Japanese and Australian Wagyu varieties
  • Exceptional wet and dry-aging process that adds plenty of flavor
  • Free of hormones and antibiotics

Cons

  • No free-shipping options

8 - D’Artagnan

Best for: People who care about humane farming practices.

D’Artagnan has been committed to free-range, natural production for over 30 years.

Even though it was poultry that made D’Artagnan famous, the company now offers various selections of different meat, including turkey, beef, pork, bison, as well as foie gras, caviar, charcuterie, truffles, and many more.

D'artagnan best meat products & gourmet choice for people

PROS

  • Incredible menu of meat and food 
  • Free-range and sustainable animal production practices
  • Hormone-free and antibiotic-free products
  • 100% customer satisfaction guarantee

Cons

  • Exclusive items could often be “out of stock”

9 - Meat N’ Bone

Best for: People looking to buy a dry-aged ribeye for special occasions.

After years of dissatisfaction with local supermarkets and online retailer meat options, three friends from Florida decided to crash the meat industry.

They started learning where Pat LaFreda and Allen Brothers bought their meat, and soon, they began building relationships with many small family-owned farms.

Today, Meat N’ Bone works with more than 35 farms from the Midwest, Australia, and Japan, to offer some of the finest dry-aged ribeyes, New York strip steaks, and Japanese Wagyu so marbled, it will melt in your hands.

Meat N' Bone delivers a superb selections of meats to your door

PROS

  • A superb selection of meats, including beef, pork, poultry, and seafood
  • Locally grown and international meats
  • Dry-aging process of up to 60 days
  • Free standard delivery with very affordable express options

Cons

  • Although the company looks promising, it is still fairly young

10 - Porter Road

Best for: People looking for locally grown pasture-raised meat.

Porter Road is a Kentucky-based online retailer that works with local farms to ensure animals are raised with love and care and treated properly.

The whole process is handled with special care, which is why they oversee how farmers raise, hand-cut, selecting the pieces, and preparing them for distribution.

Porter Road excellent quality meat services

PROS

  • High-quality meat from local Kentucky farms
  • Easy to order and free delivery
  • Dry-aging standard for all meats
  • Most products are shipped fresh, not frozen

Cons

  • Most popular items can sometimes be out of stock

11 - Rastelli’s 

Best for: Diverse protein lovers, including plant-based options

Rastelli’s has been active since 1976, and they offer beef, pork, chicken, seafood, and plant-based meals. The company pays special attention to quality sourcing, selection, handling, and safety of their products.

Rastelli provides superior quality meat products

PROS

  • Many protein options, which is suitable for large cookouts
  • A long tradition of providing superior quality meats
  • Antibiotic and hormone-free
  • Rewards program for repeating customers

Cons

  • No a la carte option to build your box

How Mail Order Steak Companies Changed the Game

With quality butcher shops being rarer than ever, it is important for people to have a way to acquire quality meats.

Although grocery stores and supermarkets have a good selection of different cuts, if you want to get a better quality filet mignon, pork chops, lamb chops, New York strip steak, porterhouse, roasts, tenderloin, sirloins, or your other favorite cut, you would have to go to top-quality restaurants and steakhouses.

With mail order companies, you can buy premium quality meats without ever having to leave your house. The ordering process is simple, the delivery is safe and reasonably quick, and you’ll get a chance to try some of the most amazing steaks in your life.

FAQS

Who has the best mail-order steaks?

The answer to this question is different depending on your preferences on location. We highlight Snake River Farms as our top choice, but you can easily get amazing steaks from any mail-order service we covered.

What’s better than Omaha Steaks?

Although reviews of Omaha Steaks are buzzing, and the company has a long tradition, there are some online meat providers we would label as better, such as Snake River Farms.

What is the Best Online Meat Company?

Once again, we would go with Snake River Farms.

Are there other companies like Omaha Steaks?

If you have only heard of Omaha Steaks, and want to learn more about online meat suppliers, then our buyer’s guide can definitely help you get to know more.

Which One Should You Choose?

When talking about our number one pick, we have to go with Snake River Farms. The quality of meat is exceptional, and if you really want to treat yourself, pick one of their amazing products.

We hope this list has helped you learn more about mail-order steak companies and finally fulfill your fantasy of cooking the perfect piece of meat on your grill.

Snake River Farms provides premium meats

Snake River Farms

Our #1 Recommendation

  • A wide selection of cuts with bulk buying options
  • Award-winning premium quality American Wagyu 
  • All meat is wet-aged for 21+ days
  • Highest level of food safety practices

Read These Next


The Best Meal Delivery Deals for Black Friday and Cyber Monday

Healthy Eating for the Elderly – Foods to Eat and to Avoid

What are the Different Types of Protein Powder?

Can Ingredient Meal Kits Really Teach You How to Cook?

Are Meal Delivery Services Worth It? – Our Opinion

Gluten Free Bloggers That’ll Inspire You to Try New Things