Meal Matchmaker is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

January 2, 2021

The Best Ice Cream Subscription & Delivery Services
Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

It's hard to believe that you can get ice cream delivered, but it's true! Every ice cream lover's dreams can come true with an ice cream subscription that allows you to try new flavors of ice cream every month.

If you know someone who appreciates this sweet dessert, send them a box to their doorstep. A food subscription box makes an amazing gift for a friend or family member.

The Top Ice Cream Subscription & Delivery Services

1 - Goldbelly Ice Cream Subscription (Editor's Choice)

Best match for the adventurous ice cream lover.

Goldbelly is a company known for mail-order foods and subscription gifts. Each month, you get five or six pints of ice cream (or ice cream sandwiches) in different, original flavors.

Some of the famous companies you'll get products from include Ample Hills Creamery, Jeni's Ice Cream, and Humphry Slocombe Ice Cream. The brand partners come from all over the U. S. to send delicious treats your way.

You can pick your subscription duration between 3 months, 6 months, or 9 months. If it's for someone else, the checkout form allows you to enter a gift message for the recipient.

Read our full Goldbelly review.

Goldbelly ice cream delivery service

PROS

  • Pick the length of the subscription in advance
  • Get enough ice cream in your shipment to share or last a long time
  • Every month is a surprise selection
  • Food boxes ship all over the United States

Cons

  • You cannot choose the size of your box

2 - Harry & David

Best match for someone looking to purchase items for an occasion.

The company Harry & David has different ice cream packages that you can send to someone's door. The boxes contain multiple pints and different flavors, and they have any occasion such as Congratulations, Thank You, Holiday, Get Well, and a Birthday assortment.

Many of their boxes come with free, two-day shipping. The Birthday gift box, for example, has ice cream from a boutique parlor in Omaha. The contents include chocolate ice cream, malted milk flavor, sea salt caramel, cookies and cream, and more. Everything is made in small batches and guaranteed fresh.

The best part of this ice cream subscription option is that you know what you're getting. It allows you to find ice cream flavors that you or your loved one enjoy.

Read our full Harry & David subscription service review.

Harry and David ice cream delivery service

PROS

  • Packaging includes cute, relevant messages for the occasion
  • Every box comes with four different pints
  • You can join the rewards program to save on orders
  • Perfect for people who enjoy classic flavors

Cons

  • Not a monthly subscription club

3 - eCreamery

Best match for a person who wants to create their own ice cream or gelato flavors.

eCreamery is a one-stop-shop for a wide selection of ice creams. You can pick from their selection of special occasion items, which include options such as Thinking of You, Thanks, Treat Yourself, and Comfort. Some of the packs even include cookies for the ultimate sweet pairing.

If you know what your favorites are already, you can put together your own collection of four or eight pints. eCreamery has every flavor you can think of, including Peanut Butter, Vanilla Bean, Mango Sorbet, Raspberry Sorbet, and Sea Salt Caramel Brownie.

Lastly (and amazingly), you can create something from scratch for a customized experience. Choose whether you want ice cream, gelato, or sorbet, and then select your base flavor and toppings. You can even pick the styles of the containers for your creations.

eCreamery ice cream delivery service

PROS

  • Purchases come packed in dry ice to remain frozen
  • The company ships deliveries to anywhere in the US
  • A lot of the best flavors of ice cream
  • You have the option to customize and name your pints

Cons

  • Not for anyone allergic to nuts

4 - Scoops by Daily Harvest

Best match for people seeking vegan ice creams.

You may not think that ice cream can be a healthy thing, but Daily Harvest is here to prove you wrong.

All of the subscription boxes, food, and other treats from Daily Harvest are vegan and gluten-free. They make quality "scoops" with only plant-based ingredients.

Their dairy-free ice creams come in flavors such as Strawberry, Vanilla and Salt Black Sesame, Mint Chocolate Chip, and Fudge.

You can see the list of ingredients on their site along with nutrition facts and instructions for eating it. All you have to do is let your pint sit for ten minutes out of the freezer and enjoy it.

Scoops by Daily Harvest ice cream delivery service

PROS

  • Get dairy-free versions of your favorite ice cream flavors
  • Add a pint to your order of other things from the shop
  • Great reviews
  • Get special deals when you sign up for a membership with your email address

Cons

  • No recurring per month subscriptions

5 - Amazing Clubs

Best match for people who want a new taste every month.

The ice cream club lets you experience four hand-packed, small-batch pints per month.

You get different surprise flavors each month from gourmet creameries.

If it's for a friend, you can send your recipients personalized messages with their product.

Membership to the ice cream of the month club comes with an email newsletter, which contains fun facts and details about each selection.

The duration of your food subscription can be 3 months, 6 or 12 months, or seasonal.

Amazing Clubs delivery service

PROS

  • Try different flavors every month
  • Subscribe to many clubs on the same site
  • Pick your own pricing option
  • Satisfaction guaranteed

Cons

  • Can't choose your flavors every month

6 - Jeni's

Jeni 's has locations of scoop shops all over the nation. If there aren't stores in your city, you can still taste the delicious flavors via Jeni 's pints club. 

With the pints club, you get the best ice cream delivered to your door four times per year.

Every box includes a variety of ice creams, sorbets, or frozen yogurts.

If you need gluten or dairy-free options, you can find them on the Jeni 's website.

The first subscription box comes with the brand's signature flavors, a welcome letter, and some ice cream spades.

Jeni's ice cream delivery service

PROS

  • No dyes or synthetic flavor in any pint
  • Access subscriptions, gifts, or local selections all in one place
  • Pint club ships to all US areas
  • Great way to expand your palette

Cons

  • Can't personalize your subscription

Perks of Delivered Ice Cream

Getting food delivered is always a great time. You don't have to leave your house, and you don't have to prepare it. Some other perks to sending ice cream or gelato to others include:

  • Finding new flavors
  • Getting rewards and coupons
  • A bit of fun for everyone
  • An original idea for a present

You really can't go wrong.

FAQS

Is there an ice cream of the Month Club?

Yes, some of the above links allow you to buy an ice cream subscription. For example, Amazing Clubs Ice Cream of the Month Club sends you a range of your favorite flavors to your door monthly. You get to try new ones each month!

Can you send someone ice cream?

You can! The best way to tell someone thanks (or sorry) is to get them an ice cream subscription. Companies offer the best gourmet food options at a great price. Most of them pack the boxes with dry ice to make sure it doesn't melt.

What to get someone who loves ice cream?

Get them an ice cream subscription so they can get delicious gelato or ice cream made from scratch to their door. If you know what flavors they like, pick an ice cream club that allows you to put together the perfect surprise. If you don't know their taste, then go for a pick such as a Goldbelly Ice Cream Subscription, where every month is a surprise.

Final Thoughts

Whether you like candy in your ice cream, gelato, or a sea salt caramel crunch, you can find an ice cream subscription to match. We find Goldbelly to be the best choice because their website has tons of other food subscription packages as well. They also have an awesome rewards program for members.

Goldbelly ice cream delivery service

Goldbelly Ice Cream Subscription

Our #1 Recommendation

  • Pick the length of the subscription in advance
  • Get enough ice cream in your shipment to share or last a long time
  • Every month is a surprise selection
  • Food boxes ship all over the United States

Read These Next


What Are the Best Cake Delivery Services?
Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

Sizzlefish Review: What’s the Scoop on This Sustainably Sourced Seafood Delivery Service?

The CookBook App Review: Everything You Need to Know

What Are the Best CBD Coffee Delivery Services?
Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

Our Review of Addictive Wellness and Their Sugar-free, Gluten-free, Vegan, and Paleo Chocolates with Elixir Blends

Bota Box Wine Review: Do These Low Carb, Low Calories Wines Taste Good? Our Honest Review