Meal Matchmaker is a reader-supported site. Purchases made through links may earn a commission. Learn more.

My Favorite Ice Cream Subscription Boxes (Updated 2023)

Written By: Paul

If you’re looking for the right ice cream subscription that can match all your preferences, you’ve stumbled onto the right article!

I’ve personally tried a ton of ice cream monthly subscriptions; everything from established creameries like McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams to the innovative and artisanal flavors of Jeni’s Pint Club.  

After an extended period of receiving constant ice cream delights, I was able to narrow down my list of favorite ice cream subscription boxes through the following criteria: 

  • Variety of flavors offered
  • Overall ice cream quality
  • Order and delivery frequency
  • Pricing options
  • Customer reviews online
  • Ability to accommodate dietary restrictions
  • Delivery coverage
  • Packaging materials.

Ready to check out some of the best ice cream subscriptions you can try today? Let’s get started!

Here’s the summary of my best picks

There’s nothing more satisfying than getting a package from a subscription service that provides everything that I love about ice cream. 

To make things more convenient, I summarized my top choices into a chart that you can easily refer to:

Company

Why Should You Try It?

Pricing

  • Partners with the best brands in the US
  • Each flavor is original
  • Ships all around the country

$89.95 per month

  • Easy to ship to multiple addresses
  • Guaranteed quality and freshness
  • Offers both classic and unique flavors

$74.99 per box

  • Covers a wide variety of special occasions
  • Huge selection of flavors
  • Offers specialty assortments

$197.97 for 3-months minimum

  • Flavors are made by gourmet creameries
  • Option for personalized messages
  • Excellent pricing

$78.95 per month

  • Flat-rate shipping
  • Detailed packaging
  • Artisanal flavors

$199 for 3-months minimum

  • Uses cutting-edge ice cream-making equipment
  • Has been operating for 70 years
  • Supports sustainable practices

$195  for 3-months minimum

  • Melt-free guarantee
  • Vegan-friendly options
  • Recyclable plant-based packaging

$75 per month

Full Review of the Best Ice Cream Subscription Boxes

Finding the ideal ice cream subscription service for you will come with many considerations. Let’s dive into my all-time favorite picks and exactly why I chose them:

1. Goldbelly Ice Cream Subscription (Editor's Choice)

  • Flavor selection: Varies depending on the brand partners 
  • Quality of the ice cream: Artisanal, Gourmet, Handmade 
  • Frequency: One-time orders, Monthly subscription
  • Price range: $89.95 per month 
  • Customer reviews: 4.7 stars 
  • Dietary restrictions and preferences: Vegan, Kosher, Nut-Free, Gluten-Free  
  • Customization options: None 
  • Delivery area: Everywhere in the US 
  • Packaging and delivery options: Packages are frozen with dry ice or ice packs 

Goldbelly is a company known for mail-order foods and subscription gifts. They are a curated online marketplace of the best gourmet foods from small shops and restaurants across the nation. Each month, you get five or six pints of ice cream (or ice cream sandwiches) in different, original flavors.

Some of the famous companies you'll get products from include Ample Hills Creamery, Jeni's Ice Cream, and Humphry Slocombe Ice Cream. The brand partners come from all over the U. S. to send delicious treats your way.

Goldbelly ice cream delivery service

PROS

  • Pick the length of the subscription in advance
  • Get enough ice cream in your shipment to share or last a long time
  • Every month is a surprise selection
  • Food boxes ship all over the United States

Cons

  • You cannot choose the size of your box
  • Subscription boxes do not always cater to dietary restrictions and preferences
  • Subscription boxes are not customizable

2. Harry & David

  • Flavor selection: 8 assortments and samplers 
  • Quality of the ice cream: Handcrafted, Traditional, Innovative 
  • Frequency: One-time orders 
  • Price range: $74.99 per box 
  • Customer reviews: 3.5 stars 
  • Dietary restrictions and preferences: Limited to ingredient listings 
  • Customization options: None
  • Delivery area: Everywhere in the US 
  • Packaging and delivery options: Trucked under controlled temperatures  

Harry & David has different ice cream packages that you can order or send to someone's door. The boxes contain multiple pints and different flavors, and they have any occasion such as Congratulations, Thank You, Holiday, Get Well, and a Birthday assortment. Many of their boxes come with free, two-day shipping.

The best part of this ice cream subscription option is that you know what you're getting – everything is made in small batches and guaranteed fresh.  It allows you to find ice cream flavors that you or your loved one enjoy.

Harry and David ice cream delivery service

PROS

  • Packaging includes cute, relevant messages for the occasion
  • Every box comes with four different pints
  • You can join the rewards program to save on orders
  • Perfect for people who enjoy classic flavors

Cons

  • No recurring subscription available for just ice cream products
  • Mixed reviews online
  • Limited flavors
  • No customization options for assortments

3. eCreamery

  • Flavor selection: 24 
  • Quality of the ice cream: Gourmet, Premium, Handmade 
  • Frequency: One-time orders, Monthly subscription
  • Price range: $197.97 for 3-months minimum  
  • Customer reviews: 4 stars 
  • Dietary restrictions and preferences: Gluten-free, Nut-free, Dairy-free 
  • Customization options: Available 
  • Delivery area: Everywhere in the US  
  • Packaging and delivery options: Shipped in reusable containers with dry ice 

eCreamery is a one-stop shop for a wide selection of ice creams. You can pick from their selection of special occasion items, which include options such as Thinking of You, Thanks, Treat Yourself, and Comfort. Some of the packs even include cookies for the ultimate sweet pairing.

If you know what your favorites are already, you can put together your own collection of four or twelve pints.

eCreamery ice cream delivery service

PROS

  • Purchases come packed in dry ice to remain frozen
  • The company ships deliveries to anywhere in the US
  • A lot of the best flavors of ice cream
  • You have the option to customize and name your pints

Cons

  • Each single order requires a minimum selection of four pints
  • Limited basic flavor choices

4. Amazing Clubs

  • Flavor selection: Varies depending on the producer 
  • Quality of the ice cream: Boutique, Premium, Handcrafted  
  • Frequency: Monthly subscription, Every-other-month
  • Price range: $78.95 per month 
  • Customer reviews: 4.6 stars 
  • Dietary restrictions and preferences: Varies depending on the producer 
  • Customization options: None 
  • Delivery area: Everywhere in the US 
  • Packaging and delivery options: Specialty protective packaging  

Amazing Clubs Ice Cream of the Month Club lets you experience four hand-packed, small-batch pints per month. The duration of your food subscription can be 3 months, 6 or 12 months, or seasonal and you get different surprise flavors each month from gourmet creameries. If it's for a friend, you can send your recipients personalized messages with their product.

Membership to the Ice Cream of the Month Club comes with an email newsletter, which contains fun facts and details about each selection.

Amazing Clubs delivery service

PROS

  • Try different flavors every month
  • Subscribe to many clubs on the same site
  • Pick your own pricing option
  • Satisfaction guaranteed

Cons

  • Can't choose your flavors every month
  • No one-time orders
  • Flavors you may enjoy have limited availability

5. Jeni's

  • Flavor selection: 47 
  • Quality of the ice cream: Handmade, Artisan, Unique recipes and texture 
  • Frequency: One-time orders, Monthly subscription 
  • Price range: $199 for 3-months minimum
  • Customer reviews: 4.7 stars  
  • Dietary restrictions and preferences: Dairy-free, Gluten-free 
  • Customization options: None 
  • Delivery area: Everywhere in the US 
  • Packaging and delivery options: Insulated box with plenty of dry ice

Jeni 's Ice Cream has locations of scoop shops all over the nation. If there aren't stores in your city, you can still taste the delicious flavors via Jeni 's Pint Club. Every box includes a variety of ice creams, sorbets, or frozen yogurts.

If you need gluten or dairy-free options, you can find them on the Jeni 's website. The first subscription box comes with the brand's signature flavors, a welcome letter, and some ice cream spades.

Jeni's ice cream delivery service

PROS

  • No dyes or synthetic flavor in any pint
  • Access subscriptions, gifts, or local selections all in one place
  • Pint club ships to all US areas
  • Great way to expand your palette

Cons

  • Can't personalize your subscription
  • Each single order requires a minimum selection of five pints

6. McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams

  • Flavor selection: 31 
  • Quality of the ice cream: Made with state-of-the-art equipment 
  • Frequency: One-time orders, Monthly subscription 
  • Price range: $195 for 3-months minimum
  • Customer reviews: 4 stars 
  • Dietary restrictions and preferences: Organic, Dairy-free, Kosher 
  • Customization options: None 
  • Delivery area: US nationwide except Alaska 
  • Packaging and delivery options: Insulated frozen shipper box

McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams has been operational for 70 years and offers nothing short of the best ice creams on the market! 

Their products are made from high-quality ingredients and special recipes. You can rest assured that each pint is smooth, pure, and rich. 

McConnell’s  Ice Cream sources its milk and cream from a family-owned farm and offers over 30 special flavors to choose from

McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams

PROS

  • Rich family history in ice cream-making
  • Uses cutting-edge ice cream technology
  • Products are certified Kosher and many are gluten-free
  • Wide range of flavors

Cons

  • Each single order requires a minimum selection of four pints
  • No customization options for subscription boxes

7. Salt & Straw

  • Flavor selection: 21 
  • Quality of the ice cream: Handcrafted, Seasonal flavors 
  • Frequency: One-time orders, Monthly subscription 
  • Price range: $75 per month 
  • Customer reviews: 4.6 stars 
  • Dietary restrictions and preferences: Vegan-friendly 
  • Customization options: Available 
  • Delivery area: Everywhere in the US
  • Packaging and delivery options: Shipped with dry ice and recyclable liners made from renewable plant-based components

Every month, Salt & Straw delivers five pints of delectable ice cream from their fresh and unique lineup of flavors!

Their products range from beloved classics to unbelievably delicious innovations and are formulated through collaborations with local farmers and chefs. You also have the option to go with vegan or seasonal flavors for your shipment.

Salt & Straw

PROS

  • Collaborates with local artisans, farmers, and chefs
  • Offers seasonal and vegan-friendly flavors
  • Handcrafted to perfection
  • Wide variety of flavor choices

Cons

  • Each single order requires a minimum selection of five pints
  • Not for persons with severe nut allergies
  • Subscription box customization varies depending on the season

Perks of Delivered Ice Cream

Getting food delivered is always a great time. You don't have to leave your house, and you don't have to prepare it. Some other perks to sending ice cream or gelato to others include:

  • Finding new flavors
  • Getting rewards and coupons
  • A bit of fun for everyone
  • An original idea for a present

You really can't go wrong.

FAQS

Is there an ice cream of the Month Club?

Yes, some of the above links allow you to buy an ice cream subscription. For example, Amazing Clubs Ice Cream of the Month Club sends you a range of your favorite flavors to your door monthly. You get to try new ones each month!

Can you send someone ice cream?

You can! The best way to tell someone thanks (or sorry) is to get them an ice cream subscription. Companies offer the best gourmet food options at a great price. Most of them pack the boxes with dry ice to make sure it doesn't melt.

What to get someone who loves ice cream?

Get them an ice cream subscription so they can get delicious gelato or ice cream made from scratch to their door. If you know what flavors they like, pick an ice cream club that allows you to put together the perfect surprise. If you don't know their taste, then go for a pick such as a Goldbelly Ice Cream Subscription, where every month is a surprise.

Final Thoughts

Whether you like candy in your ice cream, gelato, or a sea salt caramel crunch, you can find an ice cream subscription to match. We find Goldbelly to be the best choice because their website has tons of other food subscription packages as well. They also have an awesome rewards program for members.

Goldbelly ice cream delivery service

Goldbelly Ice Cream Subscription

Our #1 Recommendation

  • Pick the length of the subscription in advance
  • Get enough ice cream in your shipment to share or last a long time
  • Every month is a surprise selection
  • Food boxes ship all over the United States

Hi, I'm Paul. Welcome to my website! I, along with my cronies, are leveraging our years of working in the food industry to review meal and drink delivery services. We review. You eat happily ever after.

Read These Next


Sun Basket vs Purple Carrot: Which is Best for You?

Sun Basket vs Purple Carrot: Which is Best for You?

Can You Meal Prep Steak? (Yes, Here’s How)

Can You Meal Prep Steak? (Yes, Here’s How)

How Long to Air Fry Frozen Sticks (+Essential Guide)

How Long to Air Fry Frozen Sticks (+Essential Guide)

CookUnity vs Factor – Which Meal Service is Better for You?

CookUnity vs Factor – Which Meal Service is Better for You?

10 Best Meats for Healthy and Delicious Meal Prep

10 Best Meats for Healthy and Delicious Meal Prep

Your Essential Cheap/Budget Grocery List for Meal Prep (+ Tips)

Your Essential Cheap/Budget Grocery List for Meal Prep (+ Tips)