#2nd Best choice
#3rd Best Choice
The world of cookies is so much bigger than chocolate chip and sugar cookies. However, your local store may only carry a few typical types of cookies. While there's nothing wrong with the classics, you and other cookie-lovers deserve options from skilled bakers without leaving your home.
A cookie subscription box is a perfect way to try new cookie flavors from artisans and small businesses. Additionally, a cookie shipment lets you always have access to a delicious snack or dessert. The following is my list of the best places to order boxes of tasty treats.
Cookie subscription boxes also make a great gift pack for someone who has a sweet tooth. Give them a sample selection of premium chocolate chip or any other flavors for a way to make them smile.
Table of Contents
- 1 My Top Cookie Subscription Box & Delivery Services
- 2 Why Get a Subscription Box of Cookies?
- 3 Getting Innovative Flavors of Cookies
- 4 Making Worthwhile Gifts
- 5 In Review
My Top Cookie Subscription Box & Delivery Services
1. Mrs. Fields (Editor's Choice)
- Best match for people who would love a selection of gourmet classic cookies.
Mrs. Fields delivers a variety of cookies all over the country. The company has gourmet cakes, cookies, and gift boxes. The website has a long list of differently themed packages of treats. When browsing through it, I was happy to learn that they’ve prepared options for any occasion. Some of their themes include Father's Day, Mother's Day, Christmas, Valentine's Day, anniversaries, Halloween, and birthdays.
The boxes come in a variety of sizes, so you can get anywhere from a dozen to 90 cookies delivered. For the purposes of this review, I ordered a dozen cookies of each flavor. The cookies also come regular-sized and bite-sized, and the flavors include sugar, macadamia nut, double chocolate, oatmeal, and chocolate chip cookies.
My personal favorites were their classic chocolate chip cookies, although I’ve got to say that the oatmeal flavor was also delicious. There are so many items that you can certainly find the perfect mix of goods to order. If you want something specific, you can create a custom cookie tin or a specialized corporate gift box. When you join their email club, you can get special discounts and offers to use on your choice of cookies.
Each one of my shipments of treats came in sealed packaging to preserve the freshness. I ate a few right out of the box and they tasted just fine, but they truly won me over once I popped them in the oven, emulating that warm, freshly baked experience.
2. Goldbelly Monthly Cookie Subscription
- Best Match For: Food enthusiasts who want a marketplace that can offer them exclusive and gourmet dishes, sweets, meats, meal kits, pizzas, and pretty much anything food-related.
- Commitment Level: One-time orders; 3, 6, 9, or 12 month subscriptions
- Availability: All 50 states
- Value: Prices and shipping fees vary depending on select items
- Type: A curated online marketplace of the best gourmet foods from small shops and restaurants across the nation.
The Goldbelly company has all sorts of subscription boxes, so of course, their cookie subscription clubs deserve attention. With a monthly cookie subscription, I got enough cookies to feed six to eight people. Every month, the cookies are hand-selected from bakeries all over the country. If you’re anything like me, then you’ll appreciate the variety of experience that comes with this approach.
This subscription box is best for adventurous cookie lovers. You never know what you may get, and the variety of flavors includes ginger snap, truffle-stuffed, cream-filled, chocolate chunk, shortbread, and more types of cookies. I found it thrilling to open up each new box during my three-month-long subscription just to see what Goldbelly could surprise me with. I also appreciated the option to see examples of past items before placing my order.
I liked Goldbelly’s monthly cookie box subscription model because I was able to choose the duration of my membership. You can pick from three, six, nine, or 12-month-long cookie subscriptions. If you want even more sweet treats, you can also go for a variety of non-subscription cookie boxes. My personal favorite was the mouth-watering "Gooey on the Inside" six-pack. With Goldbelly, you can also try out customizable offers from different bakeries.
Check out our full review of Goldbelly's subscription service.
3. Harry & David
- Best Match For: People looking for unique gifts for every occasion, ranging from gourmet foods to gift of the month clubs.
- Commitment Level: No commitments - Order at any time; Subscription
- Availability: Anywhere in the US
- Value: Gift prices can vary significantly depending on what you choose; $6.99-$23.99 shipping fee for orders under $150; 16% shipping fee for orders over $150; Additional $9.99 charge for deliveries to Hawaii and Alaska; Additional $5.99 to PO Box deliveries
- Type: Exclusive gifts, gift baskets, fruit boxes, premium chocolates, baked goods, gourmet food, wine clubs, and more.
Much like Mrs. Fields, the Harry & David company has a wide variety of cookie boxes. It's not a monthly cookie subscription per se, but I could easily set up recurring orders for my favorite boxes, which is why I think it’s fitting to include Harry & Devid in my list. With so many flavors of cookies, you can easily get a loved one their favorites, delivered straight to their doorstep.
Harry & David offers a Holiday Cookie Bento Box, Gingerbread Cookies, Christmas Cookies and Truffles, Cookie Dough, Thank You Gift Basket, Birthday Basket, and an Elegance Gourmet Box. Each box has a description of the items inside. I always knew exactly what kind of treats I was going to find in the package. For example, the Elegance box has chocolate cake, shortbread cookies, almonds, and sparkling wine.
Each treat is crafted by artisans, and it really shows once you take that first bite. My confidence in the quality of the cookies grew with each order. I was also happy to learn that Harry & David has a membership program called Celebrations Passport, which allowed me to save a whole bunch of money with free shipping, exclusive offers, and unlimited deliveries for a set price every month. The offer is available across the entire brand family.
Read our full review to take a closer look at Harry & David subscription services.
4. Insomnia Cookies
- Best match for someone looking for a selection of cookies for immediate consumption.
Whenever I get late-night cravings for cookies (which happens way more often than I’d like to admit), the aptly-named Insomnia Cookies is my go-to cookie delivery service. The company has locations around the US, and you can place a cookie order for immediate delivery if you are in an eligible area.
Their menu includes classic cookies such as chocolate chunk cookies, M&M cookies, sugar cookies, and chocolate chip cookies. I like to switch things up a bit from time to time, so I often found myself browsing through their deluxe cookie items as well. These include chocolate peanut butter cup cookies, s'mores cookies, salted caramel cookies, and more.
Insomnia also offers cookie cakes, brownies, and ice cream. If you want to ship cookies to another person, you can pick one of their box size options and add the quantity of cookies of your choice.
I also joined their cookie loyalty club to see what they have to offer. Being a member granted me access to all sorts of rewards, such as free shipping or additional complimentary cookies added onto my order. To join, all you have to do to sign up is enter your email address, and you can even download the company's app to place orders more easily.
5. David's Cookies
- Best match for people who love baking.
In addition to one-time purchases of cookies, the company David's Cookies has a selection of cookie subscriptions. They have a one or two-pound cookie of the month club tin. These boxes come with a different mix of cookies every month that are fresh-baked and come with free shipping. I love their ready-made cookies, but they aren’t the main reason why I added David’s Cookies to my list.
The coolest part of their cookie subscriptions is that the company also has a cookie dough club. If you want to bake your snacks yourself, you can get an assortment of dough every month. For example, some of the past subscriptions have had flavors such as chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, white chocolate, and oatmeal raisin.
Now, I’m not an experienced baker by any means, but David’s Cookies really go out of their way to make the prep and baking process as straightforward as possible, making this cookie subscription box a perfect entry point for aspiring bakers. The amount of dough is enough to make 96 cookies every month, which was more than enough to last me for an entire month. The dough is pre-formed into balls so all of your cookies will be the same. After the first shipment, your dough ships on the 4th Tuesday of every month.
If you don't want to receive a surprise each month, you can also opt to receive a box of your favorite cookie dough any time. All of David’s Cookies’ baking products are certified Kosher.
6. Cheryl's Cookies
- Best match for a person who likes interesting flavors and shapes of cookies.
Cheryl's Cookies has a pack of cookies for any holiday or season. Their selection of cookies comes in innovative flavors and shapes such as apples, pumpkins, and flowers. I love cookies that look as good as they taste, and I knew that I was in for a treat with Cheryl's Cookies as soon as I took my first bite.
The company allows you to create your own box of up to 200 cookies. I had a blast when mixing and matching all the different flavors Cheryl’s Cookies has on offer, which include peanut butter cookies, frosted marshmallow cookies, chocolate birthday cookies, chocolate chip cookies, sugar cookies, orange citrus cookies, heart cookies, and many other fun varieties that you'd never find in a regular store.
Cheryl's also offers multiple cookie subscription clubs, which include the Cookie Club, Sugar-free Cookies and Brownies Club, and Buttercream Frosted Cutout Cookie of the Month Club. I was relieved to find out that I don’t have to commit to a single club, as all of the memberships are on a pay-as-you-go basis. I would hate to have to wait a few months before I could join a different cookie of the month club, especially considering how many delicious options there are to choose from! You can see everything that you will receive in each subscription.
Why Get a Subscription Box of Cookies?
Let's be honest. Baking is a fun way to bond with others and pass some time. I love to bake when I have the time, but if I had to do it whenever I got a craving for some cookies, I would have to basically live in the kitchen!
Baking cookies from scratch is much harder than it looks, even if you love it. It's also time-consuming. This is why I love cookie subscription box services, as it is a great way to get a delicious treat quickly and without any real effort on my part.
Other perks to cookie club subscriptions include:
Cookie subscriptions also saved me a bunch of times when planning large events. For example, if you have a big party coming up, no one wants to bake hundreds of cookies in all different flavors. A basket of cookies from a company will have a great-tasting selection of cookies, satisfying the palates of all your guests!
Getting Innovative Flavors of Cookies
Cookies have endless possibilities, which is why they are my absolute favorite baked treat. If you've never deviated from a chocolate chip cookie or plain sugar cookies, then it can be hard to know where to start. When you're ready to try a new selection, it helps to browse through the options from your favorite cookie subscription box company.
Goldbelly, for example, has a variety of interesting food boxes, with flavors such as:
The best thing about cookies is that it's a whole customizable treat. You can combine new flavors based on your favorite candy and get creative. If you aren't a baker, make sure to get recipes online to make an appropriate base for your cookies.
Making Worthwhile Gifts
Naturally, subscription boxes make amazing presents and surprises for a person you love or work with. If you want to take your gifts to the next level, consider adding a personal touch. Some options include:
Giving another person cookies can also be an experience for everyone else involved. You can make it into a tasting where you all taste the different flavors and pick favorites. Or, you can try to re-create some of the top picks out of the selection.
Cookie subscriptions are a great way to avoid the trials of baking. Whether you love chocolate, strawberry, or sugar, there is a subscription box, club, or delivery service with options you'll enjoy. Each month, you get a shipment of a selection of premium cookies right to your door or to the door of the box recipient.
My top pick for clubs goes by the name Mrs. Fields cookies. The company has an amazing selection, from chocolate chip to frosted chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla cookies. Though it's not a cookie subscription box with a recurring duration, they have so many flavors in every box and many great offers for all occasions. I had no trouble manually placing orders each month, as the process is super simple.
You can get a membership by joining the Mrs. Fields email list and get the advantage of deals. They also have an affiliate program where you can get a commission on every sale.
Our #1 Recommendation